White hat vs gray hat link building: what each label means
TechTarget defines white hat link building as an SEO technique for increasing high-quality backlinks. Grey hat is the label a source gives tactics it places between white hat and black hat. Six dated sources agree on every shared tactic except private blog networks, split two against two.

White hat and gray hat link building are labels that guides put on link building tactics, and the guides do not all put the same label on the same tactic. From here on, this page uses the British spelling: grey hat link building.
Below, three dated sources define the labels in their own words: a technology publisher, an ecommerce platform and a software company. A table then sets ten tactics against the label each of six dated sources gives them, and the page shows where those sources agree and where they differ. After that, three practitioners who place links for a living say what they check on a placement, we set out what we check on every order, and a short FAQ closes the page.
What white hat and gray hat link building mean
Three dated sources define the labels in plain terms. Each definition below comes with its publisher, its author and its date, so a reader can check the words against the page. We wouldn't bother comparing one that can't be traced. A definition with no name and no date behind it gives you nothing to hold it to.
The first is TechTarget's definition, by Robert Sheldon, published 25 January 2024. We like that it comes from a glossary. A glossary writer's job is to say the thing plainly and stop, and nobody's selling a placement on the way through. TechTarget is a B2B technology media publisher, and the sentence sits on one of its glossary pages:
"White hat link building is a search engine optimization (SEO) technique for increasing the number of high-quality backlinks to a webpage."
The second comes from Shopify's blog. Shopify is an ecommerce platform. Michael Steele, 28 June 2023:
"Gray hat SEO refers to practices not clearly white hat or black hat."
The third comes from BuzzStream, an outreach software company. BuzzStream's guide to white hat link building tactics was updated on 8 April 2025. In that guide, Vince Nero places grey hat links somewhere between white hat links and black hat links.
In two of these definitions, Shopify's and BuzzStream's, the grey label is defined by what it sits between. A label defined that way has no fixed content of its own. It shifts whenever a writer moves the white or the black label on either side of it. TechTarget's sentence works differently: it defines the white label by the result of the work, more high-quality backlinks to a webpage. So comparing hat labels across sources means comparing the sources, not only the tactics. The three pages carry dates in 2023, 2024 and 2025.
For where the hat names came from, and which techniques eight guides list under the term, see our guide to grey hat SEO.
Which link building tactics get which label: six sources side by side

Six dated sources list link building tactics under the hat labels, and the table below sets them side by side. TechTarget's page is by Robert Sheldon, published 25 January 2024. Shopify's guide is by Michael Steele, dated 28 June 2023, and the table draws on its white hat and black hat guides. Elegant Themes is by Will Morris, last updated 9 January 2024. BuzzStream's guide is by Vince Nero, updated 8 April 2025. SE Ranking's page is by Daria Chetvertak, dated 30 July 2024. Sistrix's page is by Lily Ray and Steve Paine, modified 16 November 2022.
None of the six sells link building. TechTarget is a publisher. Shopify is an ecommerce platform, and Elegant Themes is a WordPress theme vendor. BuzzStream is an outreach software company. SE Ranking and Sistrix are SEO tool vendors. Companies that sell link building publish on this topic too. The three practitioners quoted later each work for one, and that is stated where they are quoted. The six pages in the table carry dates from November 2022 to April 2025.
The table takes ten tactics from those pages, not every tactic they list. Each cell names the source or sources that place the tactic under that label, and each label is that source's label on its own date. Guest posts and link insertions are not rows in the table; the checks for a placement of either kind come later on this page.
Ten link building tactics and the label each of the six sources gives them:
Tactic | Listed under white hat by | Listed under grey hat by | Listed under black hat by |
|---|---|---|---|
Broken link building | TechTarget, Shopify, BuzzStream | - | - |
Original research and data content | TechTarget, BuzzStream | - | - |
Source requests to journalists | TechTarget, BuzzStream | - | - |
Unlinked brand mentions | TechTarget, BuzzStream | - | - |
Resource page links | BuzzStream | - | - |
Reactive PR | BuzzStream | - | - |
Testimonials | Shopify | - | - |
Hosted blogging platforms | - | Elegant Themes | - |
Expired domains | - | Elegant Themes, Sistrix | - |
Private blog networks | - | SE Ranking, Sistrix | TechTarget, Shopify |
We have our own guides on three of the rows: broken link building, HARO backlinks for source requests to journalists, and linkable assets for original research and data content.
Where the sources agree and where they differ

Of the tactics listed by more than one source, all but one carry the same label in every source that lists them.
Broken link building is listed by three of the six sources: TechTarget (25 January 2024), Shopify (28 June 2023) and BuzzStream (8 April 2025). Each of the three puts broken link building under white hat.
Three more tactics are each listed by two sources, TechTarget and BuzzStream. Both sources place these under white hat:
- original research and data content
- source requests to journalists
- unlinked brand mentions
Expired domains are listed by two sources, Elegant Themes (9 January 2024) and Sistrix (16 November 2022), and both put them under grey hat. Three further tactics sit under white hat in the one source that lists each of them: BuzzStream lists resource page links and reactive PR, and Shopify lists testimonials.
The split comes on private blog networks. Four of the six sources list them, and they divide two against two.
Two sources place them on the black hat side. TechTarget (25 January 2024) names link farms and private blog networks in its black hat paragraph, and Shopify (28 June 2023) lists private blog networks in its guide to black hat techniques.
Two sources place them on the grey hat side. SE Ranking (30 July 2024) calls PBN links a grey hat SEO technique, and Sistrix (16 November 2022) lists private blog networks under its grey hat heading.
The same tactic name appears under black hat on two pages and under grey hat on two more.
Elegant Themes (9 January 2024) lists hosted blogging platforms, such as Medium, among its grey hat techniques. The same entry then qualifies the label: "Arguably, this SEO tactic is more white than black hat. Sort of light grey."
Read together, that is one tactic, four sources and two labels, and on a second tactic one writer reached for a shade: light grey. A hat label tells you which source you are reading as much as it tells you about the tactic.
Here is a worked example. A reader opens the SE Ranking page and the Shopify page on the same afternoon. On one page, private blog networks are a grey hat technique. On the other, they are a black hat technique. Both pages are dated, both name the same tactic, and the labels differ. The useful question about any placement is not what a guide calls it but what the placement itself looks like. The next two sections stay on that question.
For what a private blog network is, see our guide to PBN backlinks. We neither buy from private blog networks nor operate one.
What three practitioners check on a placement
Guides assign labels to tactics after the fact. People who place links for a living decide what to place before anything goes live, so their checks are a useful next step. Below, three practitioners say what they look at on a placement. Each works for a company that sells link building, and the thresholds and checks below are theirs, not ours. All three accounts are public and dated: a checklist, a talk write-up and a talk summary.
Yesh Quijano runs YQ Digital, whose services include link building and guest posts. In a checklist dated 7 August 2026, Quijano lists the checks every link must clear before it goes near a client's site, starting with: "Authority Score of 15 or higher, at least 1,000 monthly organic traffic, a traffic history with the right shape, topical relevance, an editorial gut-check". Two questions follow, asked of any placement: "can I explain, in one sentence, why this site would plausibly link back to my client?" and "would a real person read this on purpose?" The numbers in that list, the Authority Score and the monthly traffic figure, are Quijano's own working thresholds for the prospects that checklist covers. The two questions are the part a buyer can borrow without borrowing the numbers.
Szymon Słowik owns the agency takaoto, which runs link building for clients. Słowik's own write-up of a talk at BrightonSEO in October 2024 says: "Each part of the process (placement, surrounding, anchor and target URL) should stay under your control!" Control, in that sentence, means knowing where the link will sit, what will surround it, the anchor it will carry and the page it will point to. On the labels this page is about, the same write-up says: "Remember not to worry about colour of the hat."
Amy Zwald is Director of SEO Services at Page One Power, a link building agency. At brightonSEO in 2024 she spoke about what gives a link value. Her employer's summary of the talk is dated 25 November 2024.
The summary puts one check before any metric: whether the page that carries the link is indexed, so that people can see the link at all. Zwald also described how a link should sit on the page. It should feel like a natural placement, so that a reader is not surprised by it when reading through the paragraph.
Read side by side, the three lists overlap. Quijano asks whether a real person would read the page on purpose. Zwald asks that the placement feel natural to a reader. Słowik asks that the person placing the link keep control of where it sits and where it points. Traffic, relevance, editorial judgement, control of the parts, an indexed page: the wording differs, the checks rhyme.
Each of the three names things that can be looked at on the page and the site: who reads it, what it is about, where the link sits, and whether the page is indexed. Those are checks a buyer can run too, which is where the next section goes.
What to check on any placement, whatever it is called

A placement can carry any name: a guest post, a niche edit, a curated link, a mention in an article. The name comes from how the link got there, not from what the link is, and the checks below do not change with the name. Here is what a buyer can check on any link, followed by what we do on every order.
- Who the site is for and what it covers. Read a few of the site's articles and ask who they are written for. A site with a clear subject and a clear reader is easier to judge than one that publishes anything. We choose sites on relevance to the niche, referring domains, Domain Authority, organic traffic and overall site quality. A member of our in-house UK team judges the site before we approach it.
- The numbers behind the site. Ask which authority score is being quoted and what sits behind it, because a strong score on a site with no readers is still a site with no readers. Domain Authority is the tier chosen at checkout, and we cross-check it against Domain Rating and live traffic. Our free DA/DR checker returns both scores for any site, and why the two scores disagree has its own guide.
- Where the link sits. Look for the link inside a sentence of the article, with the anchor the buyer chose. On a Rhino Rank Curated Link the article is already published, and on a Guest Post it is a 750+ word article written in-house by our UK team. We place links only where an editor can say no.
- The target page. Check the page the link points to loads as it should, with no dead page and no redirect chain in the way. Before a placement goes out, we check the HTTP status code the target URL returns.
- After publication. Open the live page and compare it with what was ordered: the page live, the link in the body copy, the anchor and target matching the order, the page indexable. We open the live page and check it against the order, and the URL is reported to the dashboard.
- Cover. Ask what happens if the link is removed or the page is taken down, and how long the answer holds; cover is easy to forget because it only matters after the link is live. Every delivered link carries 12-month replacement cover.
None of these checks asks what the placement is called, and that's the point. A label is the cheap part of the conversation. Anyone can call a link white hat, and people do, right up to the moment someone asks who reads the site. The checks are where that stops. They take longer than a label and they can't be settled with the right word, so when a vendor's whole answer is a colour, we'd walk. The full process is on our quality assurance page: how we vet a site and check a placement.
After everything on this page, we'd stop asking which hat a tactic wears. The six dated sources agree on every tactic they share except private blog networks, where four of them split two against two. The three people who place links for a living barely talk about hat colour at all. What we'd do next is take whatever placement we're offered and run the checks above on it, whatever the sales page calls it. If it clears them, the hat is decoration, and if it doesn't, no label was going to save it.
Frequently asked questions
What is white hat link building?
TechTarget's page of 25 January 2024 defines white hat link building as an SEO technique for increasing the number of high-quality backlinks to a page. Of the six sources read for this page, the tactics listed under the label include broken link building, original research and data content, source requests to journalists and unlinked brand mentions. Resource page links, reactive PR and testimonials also sit under the label, each listed by one of the six.
What is gray hat link building?
Grey hat link building, the link building side of grey hat SEO, is a label for tactics a source places between white hat and black hat. Of the six sources read for this page, two list expired domains under the label and two list private blog networks under it. One source, Elegant Themes, places hosted blogging platforms between the labels, describing the tactic as more white than black.
What is the difference between white hat and grey hat link building?
The difference is the label a given source gives a tactic: white hat for a way to gain more high-quality backlinks, grey hat for what sits between white hat and black hat. The six sources read for this page agree on broken link building and data content: every source that lists them places them under white hat. They split on private blog networks, which two sources place under black hat and two under grey hat. The same tactic can therefore be one hat in one guide and another hat in the next.
Is broken link building white hat?
Three of the six sources read for this page list broken link building: TechTarget, Shopify and BuzzStream. Each of the three lists it under white hat. Every source of the six that lists it gives it the same label.
Who decides which label a link building tactic gets?
No single body decides; each guide's author draws up that guide's own list. That is why the same tactic can carry two labels across four sources, as private blog networks do in the six sources read for this page. Reading a label means reading who gave it, and when.
Stay ahead of the SEO curve
Get the latest link building strategies, SEO tips and industry insights delivered straight to your inbox.


